Twelve Years of Loyalty, One Question of Equality
I have been a staunch supporter of Narendra Modi ji and the BJP since 2014. For nearly twelve years, I have supported the party, promoted its policies, defended its decisions, and advocated for its leadership both online and offline.
I have not merely watched politics from the sidelines; I have actively participated in building the narrative.
But perhaps loyalty has an expiry date when questions become inconvenient.
Recent decisions by the government, coupled with the deafening silence of several BJP leaders, have left me questioning something I never thought I would question: Have we confused supporting a political party with surrendering our right to question it?
Apparently, asking questions is becoming more difficult than defending questionable decisions.
Equality: A Constitutional Principle or a Political Convenience?
Let me make one thing absolutely clear: providing justice to historically disadvantaged communities is necessary. Protecting Dalits, preventing discrimination, and ensuring equal opportunities are responsibilities of a civilised society.
But here is a rather inconvenient question: Does empowering one community require making another community feel legally unprotected or collectively guilty?
Since when did equality become a competition in which one citizen's rights must come at the perceived expense of another's?
The Constitution does not come with different editions for different castes. Article 14 speaks about equality before the law and equal protection of the laws.
Yet, whenever policies concerning caste enter the political conversation, the discussion increasingly resembles a competition in victimhood rather than a serious debate about justice.
Apparently, we have mastered the art of discussing equality while making citizens wonder whether equality applies equally to them.
The UGC Controversy and the Politics of Division
The controversy surrounding UGC regulations has raised serious concerns among sections of the general category.
Instead of addressing legitimate questions through transparent debate, clarification and constitutional safeguards, why does the political establishment so often appear comfortable allowing resentment to grow?
Is asking for safeguards against misuse somehow an act of discrimination?
Can we not protect vulnerable communities while also ensuring that innocent individuals are not subjected to injustice?
A system that protects one citizen but ignores the legitimate grievances of another is not a model of social justice. It is an invitation to social distrust.
And surely, after twelve years of political leadership built around development, nationalism and Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas, we can expect a more thoughtful approach.
Laws Must Deliver Justice, Not Fear
Consider the debate around the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.
The objective of this legislation is important and its protections are necessary. However, concerns about procedural fairness, allegations of misuse and the rights of accused individuals deserve serious discussion.
There is a difference between protecting victims and assuming that every allegation is automatically beyond scrutiny.
There is also a difference between demanding accountability and weakening a law designed to protect vulnerable citizens.
The answer cannot be to dismiss every concern as caste prejudice.
If a law is just, it should withstand questions. If its implementation has weaknesses, those weaknesses should be addressed.
And if political leaders believe that making a law more stringent is always the answer, perhaps they should also explain what safeguards exist to prevent injustice.
Justice should not depend on the caste of the complainant, the accused, or the political convenience of the government.
Dear BJP Leadership, A Little Reminder About Loyalty
For years, supporters have defended the government against criticism. We have argued about development, national security, infrastructure, foreign policy and countless other issues.
But does the leadership believe that supporters are only useful when they are applauding?
Are we party workers and supporters merely a digital army expected to defend every decision, regardless of its consequences?
When questions emerge, where are the leaders who should be explaining the government's position?
When concerns arise among ordinary supporters, why is the response so often silence?
A political party should not confuse a loyal supporter with an unquestioning follower.
We supported the BJP because we believed in its promises, its leadership and its vision for India. We did not sign an agreement to stop thinking independently.
One Constitution. One Country. Equal Citizenship.
India cannot build a strong future by turning communities against each other.
A Dalit citizen deserves justice. A forward-caste citizen deserves justice. An OBC citizen deserves justice. Every Indian deserves equal dignity, protection and access to the law.
Social justice and constitutional equality are not enemies. They must work together.
The government must ensure that genuine victims receive protection, that discrimination is punished, and that allegations are handled through a fair legal process.
That is not anti-Dalit. That is not anti-BJP. That is simply pro-Constitution.
And Finally, A Political Reality Check
Perhaps the BJP leadership should remember one thing: elections are not won by slogans alone.
They are won through trust.
Supporters can tolerate criticism of their party. They can defend difficult decisions. They can disagree with opposition parties. But what becomes difficult to defend is the feeling that their own concerns are no longer worth addressing.
Maybe Modi ji will win again. Maybe he will lose. Elections will decide that.
But one thing is certain: no political leader should assume that twelve years of loyalty guarantee another twelve years of unquestioning support.
We did not support the BJP to replace one form of inequality with another. We supported it in the hope of building a stronger, fairer India.
And if asking for constitutional equality makes someone a less loyal supporter, perhaps the problem is not with the questions.
Perhaps the problem is with those who have stopped answering them.
Jai Hind. The Constitution comes first. Always.

No comments:
Post a Comment